Volume 13: Derbyshire and Staffordshire

Select a site alphabetically from the choices shown in the box below. Alternatively, browse sculptural examples using the Forward/Back buttons.

Chapters for this volume, along with copies of original in-text images, are available here.

Current Display: Bakewell 10, Derbyshire Forward button Back button
Overview
National Grid Reference of Place of Discovery
SK 215685
Present Location
Built into interior east wall of south porch
Evidence for Discovery
See Bakewell 2.
Church Dedication
All Saints
Present Condition
Broken and worn; carving survives in deep relief on the one face (A) now visible
Description

A (broad): The remains of vertical roll mouldings survive on the right and upper left of the stone. Contained within these are the remains of a well modelled but unidentifiable knot-work pattern on the left, and the remains of the lower half of a figure with bare legs wearing a short tunic on the right; the feet are turned to the centre. One arm, bent sharply at the elbow, is visible crossing the body below the upper break; a small square object is held to the left. Chisel marks demarking the arm are still visible.

B and D (narrow) and C (broad): Inaccessible

Discussion

Diminutive profile figures holding a small book across the body feature more than once in the carved stone sculpture of this region. Indeed, a second such figure is preserved on Bakewell 29, although in this case the book is held at an angle and the figure wears a full-length robe as opposed to the shorter garment worn by the figure on no. 10. A similar figure, also wearing a long robe, but holding the book across the body at waist-height, is found on Alstonefield 5, in Staffordshire (Ills. 69, 491).

In all three instances, the figures are depicted on their own. Bakewell 10 is bounded by vertical angle mouldings on both sides, meaning no further figures were included, while that on Bakewell 29 is framed on both sides by inner and outer mouldings, and the Alstonefield figure is framed by inner and outer mouldings on the right, the vestiges of the inner moulding on the left and by a horizontal moulding below. The fragmentary nature of the pieces, while preserving these settings, means that it is not possible to determine whether the figures were part of a scheme involving a series of such figures set one above the other along the length of the monument, or were portrayed as individuals.

If part of a series, it would be tempting to regard them as part of an apostolic scheme, as seems to be preserved elsewhere —at Collingham (1) in west Yorkshire, for instance (Coatsworth 2008, 117-19). On the other hand, if they were portrayed individually, it implies that the book-bearing figures are best understood as clerics. In either case, given the association of the role of the priest with the apostolic mission of the Church found in the exegetical and homiletic literature, these figures must have been part of a programme concerned to display the Church and its pastoral role in the region.

With this in mind, perhaps the most distinctive iconographic element is the small size of the books. Many of the figures on the crosses in Sandbach Market Square, Cheshire, bear similar attributes (Bailey 2010, 99-125), and a number of sculptures in the region (Bakewell 14, Hope 1, Checkley 1-2, Ilam Estate 1) bear the possible signs of iconographic and stylistic dependence on the Sandbach monuments; this may represent another such example of this phenomenon, whereby details displayed with some prominence on the monuments at Sandbach, produced in the first half of the ninth century, provided inspiration for sculptures subsequently produced elsewhere at different dates.

Date
Probably tenth century
References
Routh 1937a, 10; Routh 1937b, 11; Sidebottom 1994, 148, 222 (Bakewell 11)
J.H.
Endnotes
[1] The following are general references to the Bakewell sculptures (other than Bakewell 1): (—) 1845b, 156; Plumptre 1847, 38, 39, 46; (—) 1852, 324; (—) 1855, 67; Hicklin and Wallis 1869, 60; Cox 1877a, 32, 36–7; Cox 1878, 37–8; (—) 1879b, 34; (—) 1885b, 502–3; Allen and Browne 1885, 355; Cox 1887, 37–8; Lynam 1895b, 157; (—) 1900, 89; Cox 1903a; Le Blanc Smith 1904a, 195; Firth 1905, 264; Arnold-Bemrose 1910, 107; (—) 1914a, 401–2; (—) 1914b, 36; Browne 1915, 219; Collingwood 1927, 136; Moncrieff 1927, 86; Tudor 1929, 91; Brown 1937, 94–5; Routh 1937a, 7–8; Routh 1937b, 8–9; Fisher 1959, 72; Thompson 1961, 218; Radford 1961a, 210; Butler 1964, 112; Taylor and Taylor 1965, I, 36; Cramp 1977, 192, 218–19; Pevsner and Williamson 1978, 71; Cramp 1985, 311; Craven and Stanley 1986, 27; Bailey 1990, 2; Jones 1993, 68; Leonard 1993, 48; Sidebottom 1994, 151; Bailey 1996, 11; Barnatt and Smith 1997, 57; Sidebottom 1999, 218; Elliott 2001–2; Sharpe 2002, 61; Hopkinson et al. 2004, 15; Blair 2005, 315, 342, 469–70; Bergius 2012, 189; Stocker and Everson 2015, 16; Ryder 2016, 13, 14, 16, 17

Forward button Back button
mouseover