Volume 13: Derbyshire and Staffordshire

Select a site alphabetically from the choices shown in the box below. Alternatively, browse sculptural examples using the Forward/Back buttons.

Chapters for this volume, along with copies of original in-text images, are available here.

Current Display: Bakewell 14, Derbyshire Forward button Back button
Overview
National Grid Reference of Place of Discovery
SK 215685
Present Location
Built into interior east wall of south porch
Evidence for Discovery
See Bakewell 2.
Church Dedication
All Saints
Present Condition
Broken; the accessible faces are in good condition
Description

The carving on A, B and D is contained by wide flat mouldings set vertically and horizontally; on B these are inset with a thin continuous roll moulding.

A (broad): A panel of wide, flat four-strand interlace carved in deep relief is set in a curved-headed panel.

B (narrow): The decoration, contained in an arched panel, consists of the upper portion of a figure, carved in lower relief than that used for the interlace on A. Awkwardly positioned, the figure is set in profile, its head discernible, centrally placed and looking to the right, at the top of the panel. One arm emerges from behind the neck (on the left), to extend, ribbon-like, around the top of the head and in front of the face where it widens to terminate in a large hand that grasps a well-formed staff-cross held diagonally across the body, such that the cross-head extends over the ‘shoulder’ and bends slightly to fill the space in the arch behind the figure’s head. The other arm, also attenuated, extends down the left-hand side of the panel, widening out at the elbow, to cross the body at ‘waist’ height, and grasp the staff-cross in an exaggeratedly large hand, placed just below the other. The lower portion of the figure is undecorated, although the carved surface is dressed. The area of the upper torso, below the protruding chin of the profile head, has been rendered as a large pellet, formed by the deeply incised lines defining the ‘upper’ arm and the staff of the cross.

C (broad): Inaccessible

D (narrow): Largely inaccessible, but some carving is visible at the top of the stone in the gap between Bakewell 14, 8 and 9. It consists of a small portion of a strand of either interlace or plant-scroll.

Discussion

The remains of the figure on B, although distorted, can be understood to depict a profile figure with a staff-cross held over the right shoulder by both hands, the left arm emerging from around the back of the head. As such, it represents one of a small group of such figures all located in this region—Leek 3, Ill. 569 (see also Hope 1, Ill. 214). Generally, in Anglo-Saxon sculpture, figures bearing staff-crosses over the shoulder face forwards (e.g. Christ ascending on Wirksworth 5, Ill. 453, or Christ in Majesty on Chesterton 1, Ill. 533). This figure, and that at Leek (and Hope), however, are in profile and have, in addition, attenuated necks and slightly stooped shoulders; they are also found in association with prominent pellets. Here, this motif occurs in the angle moulding between A and B, while the area of the chest between the staff-cross and left arm has been articulated as a pellet. Elsewhere, it has been suggested (Hawkes 1998, 41-2; 2002a, 139-41) that these Derbyshire and Staffordshire figures derive from the relatively rare iconography of the Road to Calvary featured on the early ninth-century cross of Sandbach Market Square 1 where Simon of Cyrene bearing the cross to Calvary in the company of Christ is interspersed by pellets and characterised by a slightly stooped posture, an attenuated neck and rather limp staff-cross held drooping over his shoulder (Bailey 2010, 111–12, ill. 267; see Fig. 32, p. 79). Here at Bakewell it seems that this figure type, removed from a narrative context, has been utilised to convey the ideas normally associated with the forwards-facing image of Christ bearing a staff-cross: that of the majesty of the resurrected Christ, the staff-cross itself being the symbol of the resurrection. As such, it likely represents a later response to the iconographic programme displayed in the ninth-century carvings at Sandbach, and so is probably best situated in a later ninth or tenth-century context.

Date
Possibly late ninth, but more probably tenth century
References
Le Blanc Smith 1905b, 99; Le Blanc Smith 1906, 244; Routh 1937a, 12, pl. IV a; Routh 1937b, 13–14, pl. IV a; Plunkett 1984, 272–3, 290, 356, pl. 45; Sidebottom 1994, 148, 224 (Bakewell 23); Hawkes 1998, 41–2, fig. 4; Hawkes 2002a, 139–41
J.H.
Endnotes
[1] The following are general references to the Bakewell sculptures (other than Bakewell 1): (—) 1845b, 156; Plumptre 1847, 38, 39, 46; (—) 1852, 324; (—) 1855, 67; Hicklin and Wallis 1869, 60; Cox 1877a, 32, 36–7; Cox 1878, 37–8; (—) 1879b, 34; (—) 1885b, 502–3; Allen and Browne 1885, 355; Cox 1887, 37–8; Lynam 1895b, 157; (—) 1900, 89; Cox 1903a; Le Blanc Smith 1904a, 195; Firth 1905, 264; Arnold-Bemrose 1910, 107; (—) 1914a, 401–2; (—) 1914b, 36; Browne 1915, 219; Collingwood 1927, 136; Moncrieff 1927, 86; Tudor 1929, 91; Brown 1937, 94–5; Routh 1937a, 7–8; Routh 1937b, 8–9; Fisher 1959, 72; Thompson 1961, 218; Radford 1961a, 210; Butler 1964, 112; Taylor and Taylor 1965, I, 36; Cramp 1977, 192, 218–19; Pevsner and Williamson 1978, 71; Cramp 1985, 311; Craven and Stanley 1986, 27; Bailey 1990, 2; Jones 1993, 68; Leonard 1993, 48; Sidebottom 1994, 151; Bailey 1996, 11; Barnatt and Smith 1997, 57; Sidebottom 1999, 218; Elliott 2001–2; Sharpe 2002, 61; Hopkinson et al. 2004, 15; Blair 2005, 315, 342, 469–70; Bergius 2012, 189; Stocker and Everson 2015, 16; Ryder 2016, 13, 14, 16, 17

Forward button Back button
mouseover